← RETURN TO ESSAY
ESSAY / 17 NOVEMBER 2026

What a Polish Deli Keeps

A reading of Joshua C. Blank on the difference between recognizing a place as Polish and explaining what happens there.

A person can walk into a Polish deli for groceries and come away having heard news of an old friend. Joshua C. Blank puts the deli beside the church and the bakery as one of the places where Polish people living abroad know they might find one another. That observation, on page 66 of his article, carries more weight for me than a broad statement about food and identity. It identifies something a shop can actually do.

My question is what happens to the argument after we agree that the deli preserves community. Blank moves from belonging to nostalgia and then to what he calls symbolic ethnicity. Those ideas are related, but I wanted to see the differences worked out. A customer buying the food they eat every week has one relationship to the shop. Someone making a special trip to recover a taste remembered from childhood has another. Calling both visits an expression of ethnicity gets us part of the way.

The stakes become clearer when Blank discusses decline. Food can outlast other everyday expressions of a tradition. A person who rarely uses the language may still know exactly what they came to buy. If the deli closes, a product might remain available elsewhere while the chance encounter at the counter disappears. That is a more specific loss, and one a simple inventory of foods would miss.

I finished Blank’s article persuaded that the deli matters and still wanting a more distinctly Polish account of how it matters. Much of his argument travels easily to other immigrant-owned shops. The strongest moments make me want to stay in this particular one a little longer, to learn who comes in, who recognizes whom and what they would lose if they had to shop somewhere else.

Adapted from my April 2026 University at Buffalo critical response to Joshua C. Blank, “More than Pierogi and Pączki: The Polish Deli in the Diaspora” (2024), especially pages 57–59, 66–71 and 78.

SC.

Curiosity. Craft. Conviction.